The Great Debate: Cooperate and Compete: The New Federalism – Devendra Fadnavis , Mehbooba Mufti Sayeed and Shivraj Singh Chouhan
Whatever we have asked for from the Centre, we have got. There is no discrimination
India Today Group Chairman and Editor-in-chief Aroon Purie welcomed the audience to the 16th edition of the India Today Conclave and the first in Mumbai. Commencing the conclave, Mr. Purie introduced the topic of the year- “The Great Disruption” and the speakers for the first session, The New Federalism.
The Centre is encouraging the idea of cooperative federalism which means that states play an important role in the development of the nation. All three chief ministers, Devendra Fadnavis, Mehbooba Mufti Sayeed and Shivraj Singh Chouhan, agreed that “Team India comprises the various states and the CMs”. “Although people say Mr Modi is authoritarian, he is not. He is open to ideas and has tried to develop the country as a true federal structure,” Mehbooba Mufti Sayeed, CM, J&K said.
Devendra Fadnavis said that certain key Mumbai projects which were pending for several years for clearances have now been approved. According to Fadnavis, the biggest disruption is the inclusion of environment aspects into the development projects of cities. In Maharashtra, the government does not need to go to Delhi for clearances for construction of up to 1 lakh square metres. “There is a huge sense of positivity,” he said.
For the development of the nation, states have to compete with each other; not parties or leaders. While Mehbooba Mufti agreed that Jammu and Kashmir is lagging behind the others, she said it’s not because of states competing with each other and appealed to the Centre and other states for “handholding.”
Even as the BJP is spreading to various states, regional parties cannot be ignored since they represent aspirations of the regional people. “While some regional parties are gone for now, they are not out,” said Mehbooba Mufti. However, she stressed on the need for the opinions of regional parties to be taken into account in key policy decisions. “Our sensitivities are different and we do have a role as far as our relationships with other countries such as Pakistan. Our role needs to be considered since we are the victims. But whenever we have asked for anything, no minister has said no. We get whatever we need,” she said.
The state of Jammu and Kashmir needs special assistance because of its sensitive nature. Mufti appealed to the Centre and other states for “handholding” since the state is lagging behind most others. “It is not because other states are competing with us; it is because we are a border state and have certain sensitivities,” she said. Article 370 is not impediment to the development of Jammu and Kashmir. Mufti invites people to visit Kashmir with their families, “enjoy the spring or the autumn of Kashmir”. She said: “Despite the encounters in certain parts of the valley, Kashmir is one of the safest places in the country where women can walk around freely.”
Despite changing political trends, in a democracy, every party continues to be important. “No party can finish off any other party, only the people can finish a party. The Prime Minister has set different standards and parties have to match or break those standards. The battle of ideas can be fought with development and ideas,” said Fadnavis.
Mehbooba Mufti: “We are the victims of the relationship between the two countries.”
Devendra Fadnavis: “The decision on demonetisation shows that it was taken with desh bhakti. Any major decisions related to defense or to RBI are exclusively the Centre’s domain.”
Shivraj Singh Chouhan: “We have cooperative federalism. The states are not discriminated against. The Niti Ayog has chief ministers from different states irrespective of their parties.”
Anecdote: When asked if the Shiv Sena, an alliance partner in the Maharashtra government, was playing the role of Fadnavis’ biggest opposition, the Chief Minister said: Our inspiration is Mr Vajpayee, if he could run a government with 22 parties, I can easily manage with one.”
INDIA TODAY CONCLAVE
Started as part of India Today’s 25th anniversary, INDIA TODAY CONCLAVE was designed as a meeting point for the best minds from India and around the world to map the geopolitical and economic future of the country. In its inaugural year the theme was India Tomorrow 2002: Opportunities and Threats with Vice President of the USA Al Gore as the chief Guest. In its second year the theme was India Tomorrow 2003: Global Giant or Pygmy? The Honorable William Jefferson Clinton, 42nd President of the United States presided as the keynote speaker. The past 14 conclaves have been widely acclaimed and popular for the quality of speakers and discussion. The speakers who have been part of this conference each year are current and former heads of state, Nobel Laureates, spiritual leaders, industry captains, social workers, economists, authors, academics, scientist, strategists, activists, cine directors, actors and sportspersons. The past conferences can be accessed at www.indiatodayconclave.com